|
Travels in Lithuania
Over the past few years I have been
fortunate to visit Lithuania a number of times. Most of my visits
have involved offering workshops for Lithuanian educators and mental health
professionals under the auspices of a group called The American Professional
Partnership for Lithuanian Education (A.P.P.L.E.) .
If you want to know
a little more about my work with this group, please see the section below
entitled About A.P.P.L.E.
If you'd like to
know a little more about Lithuanian history and culture, please see the
section below entitled About Lithuania.
If you are a traveler,
either in fact or in your imagination, allow me to introduce you to two
of my favorite places in Lithuania in the sections below entitled On
the Road to Druskininkai and On the
Road to Nida.
If you are interested
in history, Judaica, and/or the psychology of war and genocide, I offer
some thoughts and historical background in the section below entitled
The Lost Culture of Lithuania.
As you read, you
can click on the links to see associated pictures and photos. Your
comments about this site are most welcome! Please e-mail torisc@cofc.edu.
About A.P.P.L.E.
This summer and last (1997 & 1998), with
the support of the Lithuanian Ministry of Education and Science and the
College of Charleston, I had the opportunity to travel to Lithuania as
a member of the American Professional Partnership for Lithuanian Education
(A.P.P.L.E.). As a former Soviet republic, Lithuania has had limited
exposure to Western research on and innovation in teaching. Since
1991, A.P.P.L.E. has been organizing education specialists (in special
education, school administration, school psychology, curriculum development,
etc.) from the U.S. and Canada to teach seminars to Lithuanian teachers.
A.P.P.L.E continues to grow; this year, one of its founders, Vaiva
Vebra, was named vice-minister of Education and Science, which we celebrated
at a reception given for her by President
Adamkus. An American vice-minister in Lithuania is not so
unusual. The president himself was an American citizen and it is
estimated that 1 million Lithuanian Americans live in the U.S. and Canada.
(Lithuania has a population of 4 million.)
The chance to visit the
homeland of my paternal grandparents was for me a dream come true, especially
since they passed away before I got to know them. When I was growing
up, getting information about Lithuania was never very easy. I was
told that the Soviets were attempting to dismantle the culture by moving
Lithuanians out (mostly to Siberia) and replacing the populace with Russians.
By the time I reached adulthood, I figured that little would be left of
my Lithuanian heritage. Needless to say, I was pleased (and surprised)
when the citizens demonstrated for and won independence. I was even
more pleased when I arrived in Lithuania last year, and, contrary to my
expectations, found a culture that was as vibrant as it was ancient.
What follows are some
of my impressions of a storybook-like land, which, like the princess in
the fairy tale, is just awakening from a long sleep. What is amazing
is that, during her sleep, many of her treasures were somehow protected
and preserved. Her language, arts, folk songs and stories have survived.
Many of her churches, castles, and monuments are still standing and amenable
to restoration. Most importantly, her people have remained strong
in their identity and loyal to their heritage. How Lithuania survived
its Soviet occupation is an interesting story that I am still in the process
of learning, and I should note that the observations I offer here are based
mainly on my travels to just a few (southeastern) cities - Vilnius,
the capital; Kaunas, the second largest city in Lithuania;
Druskininkai, where I taught a seminar
in 1997; the nearby village of Merkine; and Moletai, where I taught
a seminar
in 1998.
About
Lithuania
Although I had a myriad
of interesting experiences in my ancestral Baltic homeland,
three general impressions seemed to prevail. The first involved a
widespread sadness related to the historical victimization of Lithuania
by some of its neighbors. War, torture, and fear are still
a part of the living memory of Lithuania. Although not an obvious
part of everyday life, one cannot go long or far without some reminders
that the recent history of these gentle people has been brutal and bloody.
Some photos representing this impression are offered in the following section
entitled Melancholy Remembrance. A second impression
refers to a pervasive artistic creativity, which seems fueled by the natural
beauty of the environment and the close relationship of the Lithuanians
to nature. Some examples of this are offered in the section entitled
Ecological
Artistry. And finally, even a short-term visitor cannot help
but experience something of the Ancient Spirituality that permeates
traditional Lithuanian customs. This is a culture comfortable with
symbolism, mysticism, and miracle. After all, the situation in Lithuania
today is itself a miracle in the making.
Melancholy Remembrance.
Lithuania is a small country (about the size of West Virginia or Ireland)
on the southeastern coast of the Baltic Sea, with Latvia to its north,
Byelorussia to its east and south, and Poland and part of Russia (Kaliningrad
District) to its south and west. During its heyday in the 14th and 15th
centuries, the Grand Duchy of Lithuania stretched from the Baltic to the
Black seas. Its more recent history consists of a series of occupations
and revolts. Lithuania enjoyed two decades of independence between
1918 and 1940, (although Poland occupied part of the country in 1920),
after which it was invaded by the Soviets, occupied by the Germans, and
then occupied by the Soviets again until its independence in 1990.
Of course, this brief historical summary gives no sense of the human suffering
underlying these facts. Many older Lithuanians still recall the fight
for freedom against the Poles. The Giedraiciai
monument
to the fallen heroes of one of these battles was so sturdily
built that the Soviets could not manage to dismantle it during their occupation.
Recently erected monuments
in Kaunas honor the fallen soldiers of these times as well. Although
I saw few World War II memorials, my discussions with many older Lithuanians
revealed a deep sense of sadness, shame, and guilt about the fate of most
of Lithuania's Jews during the Nazi occupation. This graffiti
swastika and Soviet red star on an old building in Druskininkai still
have the ability to evoke powerful feelings. An older tour guide
in Druskininkai related with tears in his eyes how the entire neighborhood
of Jews in this city vanished one night, no doubt headed for the concentration
camps. In the ancient town of Merkine, one can visit the museum in
the old Russian Orthodox church and see artifacts that span this nation's
history, including the section in the cellar referred to as "The
Dump." Here, the feelings of the people of this community toward
the Soviet occupation are clear - in the ripped Soviet flag, barbed wire,
and torn photos of Communist party leaders. A large wart has been
added to the portrait
of Lenin, and one cannot descend into the moldy cellar room with its
heaps of Russian army uniforms without stepping on bas relief images of
Lenin on the floor. Across the street from the museum is the old
KGB headquarters, once a synagogue, selected for the gruesome acts
of torture that were performed there because its thick walls muffled the
screams of the interrogators' victims. The walls of this building
now are covered with photos of mutilated bodies from the KGB's own files.
The wooden sculpture in this picture was carved by a man who, as a young
child, was forced to sit on his father's corpse while being interrogated.
The bodies of partisan resistance fighters killed by the KGB during the
Stalinist era were thrown into the town dump. Later, the field was
plowed over and used for sporting events. When the Soviets left in
1990, the remains of these victims were exhumed and buried around the edge
of this field, and a monument erected at its center. Here a grandmother
and her grandson visit the graves of two of her sons in this Merkine
cemetery. It has been estimated that Lithuania lost approximately
30% of it's population during the period of Stalin's rule. Rare is
the Lithuanian who did not have family members deported to Siberia.
Most never returned.
Even
Lithuania's achievement of its independence from the U.S.S.R. was not without
bloodshed. A peaceful protest against Soviet influence at the
radio tower in Vilnius in 1991 resulted in the death of 14 unarmed
protesters, some of them, as in this photo, crushed
by Soviet tanks. The years since independence also have been
difficult economically. Despite the beauty of its old buildings,
much of the populace of Vilnius still live in Soviet-style
tenements. The spas
of Druskininkai, a city famous for its mineral springs, are
mostly empty now. Once the communist government paid for its workers
to come to this huge
concrete resort building, where they would line up by the hundreds
for various kinds of massage and hydrotherapy. Now, few (including
Druskininkai's nearby Polish neighbors) can afford such luxuries.
One spa that did seem to have a number of clientele was the Belarus
sanitarium, where many young victims of the Chernobyl disaster
are cared for.
One
of my American psychologist colleagues in Druskininkai described Lithuania
as a nation in the throes of "post-traumatic stress." There certainly
is reason enough to explain any symptoms of such a diagnosis. Happily,
my other impressions of this land and culture suggest that these people
also have some formidable coping skills, as described below.
Ecological Artistry.
You will not need to be very long in Lithuania before you realize that
, in every means of artistic expression, whether sculpture, architecture,
music, dance, painting, crafts, literature, or lifestyle, there is a seamless
connection to nature. So, for example, after collecting your luggage
in the Vilnius airport, you will emerge into a large hall filled with old
women in babushkas who wait to greet their returning loved ones
with bouquets of flowers, each grown in one of the ubiquitous
family gardens; and these grandwomen will look as old as the dirt
that fills their wrinkled pores. At the nearby exchange window, you
will change your money into litas (each worth about 25 cents and able to
buy about as much as a dollar), and you will notice that the figure
on the 1 litas bill looks exactly like the kerchiefed old women who
fill the space around you with their earthy fragrance. This figure
is Zemaite, a pseudonym based on the name of the region in which
this anonymous 19th century author lived. She wrote of the life and
woes of the Lithuanian peasant woman when to write in her native tongue
was against the law. Suddenly you will realize that great literature
is like a grandmother, whose flowers are the life stories she brings to
us. I received many bouquets of flowers while in Lithuania.
In fact, the second time I came here, I was greeted with flowers at the
airport by my new friend Ruta, who had attended my seminar the previous
year. At the end of each A.P.P.L.E. seminar, the Lithuanian teachers
organize a grand and traditional party, replete with lots of food, champagne,
and singing - and of course, bouquets of flowers. Here I pose with
some of my colleagues
from Moletai and the bouquets of home-grown flowers we were given by
my seminar participants.
To be
in Lithuania is to sing, and the tune of choice usually is one of
the 600,000 known folk songs. Often these are of the ancient polyphonic
form called the sutartine, and performances of folk songs usually include
native
costumes and dancing.
The lyrics speak of life and death, of trees and harvest, of mother sun
and father moon. Accompaniment may be from something as simple as
a clay
whistle, or a flute fashioned from a twig. Appreciation
of music begins in childhood, and it is not uncommon to find children
performing in public with an expertise far beyond their years.
Vilnius, like large cities worldwide, also has its impromptu
street performers, and a meal at a friend's home is likely to conclude
with a round of traditional and modern songs. I must confess that
"Welcome to the Hotel California" will never sound quite the same to me
after hearing a most heartfelt version sung with a distinctly Lithuanian
accent by my friend Girenas!
Lithuania
is a land of sculpture, and don't be surprised if a walk in a park reveals
a tree
stump with human features or a grand
duke who stands as tall as a tree. Neither
should you be surprised if you see a stone
minotaur emerging from the earth. Europas Parkas, near Moletai,
is a sculpture garden where one can ponder "The
Woman" or stand beneath a hovering
boulder. From a store
sign in Kaunas, to a theatre
marquee in Vilnius, an artistic exuberance emerges. Some of the
most beautiful sculptures are in cemeteries, as in this Druskininkai
angel ; many are in parks, like this flying
girl or floating
man in one of the squares of Druskininkai; often it is just in front
of someone's home, as in this wooden brick
carrier. Crosses and other religious statues, once the mainstay
of the village, are seeing a resurgence, like this cross
in the village of Merkine. The Forest
Echo Museum in Druskininkai works to celebrate nature and preserve
the environment and presents many creative uses of forest products, as
in this unique
cafe on the premises.
Lithuanian
crafts often are based on traditions that are centuries old, from beautiful
woven linens and geometric patterned fabrics, as depicted on this loom
in the Merkine museum, to the black clay pottery being formed here
on the potter's
wheel and fired in an outdoor, hole-in-the-ground
oven , just as it was centuries ago. Ubiquitous amber
jewelry, formed from the petrified resin of trees that died 50 million
years ago, typically is unpolished. Simple materials - wood,
straw, rock, cloth, clay and paper - are the raw materials of the
craftsman, and natural objects - the sun, moon, stars, and flowers - are
the topics of their adornments. Even this graffiti
from Kaunas displays the artistic bent that seems to permeate Lithuanian
expression.
Finally,
one can get a sense of the connection between Lithuanian art and nature
in the works of one of its most famous painters, the symbolist Ciurlionis.
Two of his most famous works, Serenity
and Friendship,
like the rest of his paintings, suggest a quality both natural and
supernatural. And so it is that the creative expressions of this
culture again and again illuminate the transcendent quality of the natural
world.
Ancient
Spirituality. Many
of the Americans with whom I worked in Lithuania repeatedly expressed a
sense of something special about this place; something not quite capable
of expression in words alone; yet something that spoke to our deepest feelings.
It was not merely the surprising religiosity of this former Communist state,
although it is a touching testament to the importance of faith to witness
its renewal despite a generation of efforts to achieve its demise.
A mostly Catholic country, one can see Lithuanians join their Polish counterparts
in marches
of penance and pilgrimage, or visit the Gates
of Dawn in Vilnius, where the faithful come to pray for miracles or
to leave memorials for answered prayers. And certainly there are
churches everywhere; magnificent structures, often centuries old, like
the picturesque Catholic
church of the Holy Virgin Mary or the Eastern
Orthodox church of Druskininkai. One can marvel at the evocative
quality of the interiors of these special places, like that of the Church
of St. John's on the University of Vilnius campus, which, during Soviet
occupation, housed a science museum; or the Cathedral
in Kaunas, where I witnessed a wedding taking place. How is it
that so many sainted
visages in alabaster and gilded
gold maintained their silent vigil over these sacred grounds?
(Some, like the three saints who once topped the Cathedral in Vilnius,
did not survive, but recently have been restored.) In the Church
of St. Raphael, near my residence in Vilnius, where I was attending
the Third International Baltic Psychology Conference before my seminar
in Moletai, I dropped in on a Saturday night Mass. It was peopled
with souls young and old, and from foyer to sacristy. Here I saw
a statue
of Jesus with what appeared at first to be bloodied feet, until I noticed
on another statue nearby that, in fact, what I was seeing were the places
where the tender touches, tears, and kisses of the faithful had worn
away the paint and revealed
the
underlying wood.
Something
more also underlies the resurgent and resplendent character of Lithuania's
religious institutions. Sometimes, it does so in a most literal way,
as in the archeological discoveries of pagan altars beneath the Vilnius
Cathedral. Usually, this pervasive spiritual aspect is more subtle,
and it takes many forms. So, for example, the carefully tied oak
leaves that drape the church
in Merkine are not merely decorative. The oak tree, among others,
holds special symbolic meaning for Lithuanians. For some, hugging
a certain kind of tree is as reverential an act as kissing the wooden toes
of Christ's statue. In fact, the
tree of life , with its function of uniting the Earth (via its roots)
with the heavens (via its leaves touching the sky) is a familiar folk motif,
dating back to pagan times. In appears in artifacts both modern and
ancient, from papercuts to carvings
on towelracks, and in architecture, as in the gables on the Dainava
Center, where I stayed while teaching in Drushkininkai, and some of
the "headstones"
in a cemetery in Merkine. It even is symbolized in the structure
of the Museum
of Ethnocosmology in Utena, part of the Moletai district. Here
one enters beneath the ground level where the earliest artifacts are displayed
and ascends through the interior of the building to an observatory that
opens to the sky and reveals the pastoral
landscape of Moletai below. And the old gods are still with us,
as with Perkunas, the great god of thunder, who is memorialized in this
old
structure in Kaunas, where his statue was reputed to have been uncovered
in the walls during some renovations decades ago.
But
even more than the remnants of ancient symbols and beliefs; there is something
about this place. Perhaps it is easiest to experience in cemeteries
where headstones
seem to grow among the trees, and where, like the tree of life, death
seems to emerge from its place in the earth and reach out to embrace
the sky. Perhaps it is in the angle
of the Northern sun, which sometimes causes one to draw a reverential
breath as it captures one's vision with its selective illumination.
Perhaps it is in the undisturbed beauty of its lakes and landscapes, as
in the evening
view of Lake Bebrusai, or in its spectacular sunsets,
as in this one in Moletai. Whatever it is, it draws one back.
I can recommend this place to any traveler; a place where one can experience
a people who know how best to make peace with their history, to live their
artistry, and to surround themselves with what is both most simple and
most sublime. With luck, I shall return to this homeland of my ancestors,
and these impressions will represent a beginning rather than The
End.
On the Road to Druskininkai
On the Road to Nida
The Lost Culture of Lithuania
It
was my third visit to Lithuania. I was teaching a workshop with two
American colleagues. Our students were mental health professionals.
My colleagues separated the class into groups and gave each group a piece
of paper about one by two meters large and a box of colored markers.
"Draw a picture of Lithuania as you see it," they instructed. My
group got right to work. Soon, it became apparent that they were
depicting the highlights of Lithuanian history. On the left side
was the past; an ancient altar, Gedimas' castle, a knight on horseback;
on the right side was the future; a large mountain being scaled by small
figures, happy faces emerging at the other side, a bright shining sun.
When they were finished, they sat back and looked at me, satisfied.
I couldn't help but notice and point out to them that there was a large,
empty space in the middle of their drawing. "What," I asked in all
innocence, "is missing?" My group seemed momentarily stunned.
What had they forgotten? Then, slowly, one woman picked up the yellow
marker and drew two jagged lines, like lightening bolts, demarcating the
distant, glorious past from the present struggles and bright hopes of the
future. Another student picked up the red pen and within those lines
drew prison bars; then another added small faces with mouths opened as
if to wail. Someone else added a hammer and sickle, another a swastika
and a star of David. They then sat there quietly, their mood now
completely changed. In fact, each of them looked close to tears.
How could they have forgotten? As a psychologist I know that one
way we deal with our saddest memories is to overshadow them, to "white
them out." But sometimes when we do this, they become even more conspicuous
by their absence. And no less painful. And what of me?
This was my third visit to Lithuania. Although I was not unaware
of her recent history, I was only now coming to realize the magnitude of
its effects on the people around me, including people who themselves had
not directly experienced it. And so, like my Lithuanian counterparts
in the
drawing group, I struggle to understand.
Here are some of
the historical facts of this sad part of Lithuania's
living memory. On June 15, 1940, the day when the German Wehrmacht
entered Paris, the Red Army of the Soviet Union occupied Lithuania.
Soviet occupation exacted a terrible toll on Lithuania, including massive
deportations of Lithuanian citizens. But soon the Soviets were driven
out by the German Barbarossa offensive. When, on June 24, 1941, Hitler's
Wehrmacht troops marched into Lithuania, they were greeted by many citizens
as liberators. The invading Nazis wasted no time. During the
nights of June 25-26, 1941, the infamous Einsatzgruppen, whose job it was
to eliminate Jews, took 1,500 victims in the city of Kaunas. By February,
1942, SS Colonel Karl Jäger reported to Berlin that more than 136,000
Jews had been executed. The surviving Jews were crowded into ghettos
until the next phase of killing occurred in 1943 with the systematic destructions
of the Kaunas and Vilnius ghettos. (1a, pps. 350-352) Ultimately,
over 200,000 Jews were killed in Lithuania. This number represents 90 percent
of the Jewish population of the country, the highest proportion of victims
among all Jewish communities in Europe. (2) But what is most troubling
for Lithuanians is that sad fact that many of its citizens, perhaps the
family members and neighbors of my adult students, were collaborators with
the Nazis in their heinous crimes. In a speech to the Seimas (parliament)
on September 20, 2001, Alfonas Eidintas reported that materials in Lithuanian
archives suggested that over half of those killed were killed by local
police forces - Lithuanians - under the guidance and the organization of
the Nazis. (3, p.8) On the other hand, some Lithuanians did risk their
lives to try to save their Jewish neighbors. But an examination of
the historical facts reveals that, even if they were not Nazi collaborators,
most Lithuanians did nothing to stop the Jewish genocide. Looking
back at the evidence that has survived from this terrible and chaotic time,
what can we learn to help us to understand this tragedy? Although
far beyond the scope of this essay, our ultimate task should be to try
to answer a question posed by Markas Zingeris, signatory of the Lithuanian
Act of Independence, member of the Seimas, and Director of the State Jewish
Museum 'Why (do) the same conditions awaken the beast in one person and
righteous behavior in another?" (1, p.27) Let us explore what is
known by borrowing the structure represented in Raul Hilberg's last book
(3) and consider the past through the circumstances of the key players
the victims, the perpetrators, and the bystanders.
The victims. Despite
this recent tragic chapter of the Jewish presence in Lithuania, its history
is a long and rich one. The first Jewish families sought asylum there
as early as the 12th Century, (1a, p.339) making them one of the oldest
ethnic communities in the country. (1b, p.24) Many more Jews were attracted
by the welcome and guarantee of safety extended by Grand Duke Gediminas
in 1323. Another Lithuanian Grand Duke, Vytautas the Great, elevated the
Jews who had come to Lithuania to the status of the gentry, thus declaring
them free people. (4, p.17) For a while they were the world's largest
Jewish community and the period from 1580 1648, during the Lithuanian-Polish
union, has been referred to as the Golden Age of Lithuanian Jewry.
But again, fate took a turn. During the cossack uprising against
Polish landlords in 1648, between 100,000 to 300,000 Jews were killed in
an area that included present-day Lithuania. Despite this, Lithuania
continued to grow as an important Jewish religious and intellectual area,
represented by the famous rabbi and Talmudic scholar from Vilnius, Elijah
ben Solomon Zalman, (1720-1797), the
great Gaon of Vilnius. In 1755, 750,000 of Europe's 1.25 million
Jews lived in Poland-Lithuania. During the 19th Century, Lithuania
was ruled by the Russian Czars, and their approach to the Jewish community
varied from liberal acceptance to repression, depending upon who was in
power. Nonetheless, a Jewish world, known widely as Litvakia and
based on religious traditions and the Yiddish language, thrived. After
World War I the three Baltic Republics (Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia)
regained their independence, although Vilnius, the traditional Lithuanian
capital, was occupied by Poland and eventually annexed to it. Kaunas became
the provisional capital. Vilnius was quite impoverished and life was difficult,
yet this time and place contributed an amazingly vibrant Jewish life, including
the outstanding Jewish Institute of Research (YIVO), the Teachers' College,
and the Strashun Library. It was at this time that Vilnius became
widely known as the Jerusalem of Lithuania. The cultural life of
the Jewish community of Kaunas was more provincial, but also more comfortable.
Jews from the Kaunas area controlled a significant proportion of Lithuania's
commerce and industry. Famous Litvaks who began their professional
careers in Lithuania about this time include the mathematician H. Minkovski,
the world-famous violinist and musician J. Heifetz, the creator of the
Esperanto language L. Zamenof, the father of modern Hebrew E. ben
Yehuda, the sculptors M. Antokolski and Z. Lipshitz, the artist I. Levitan,
and the creator of the modern Hebrew novel A. Mapu. (1a, p.340-350); (4,
p.13).
The fate of Lithuanian
Jews during World War II can be understood only in the context of the invasion
of Lithuania by the Soviet Red Army following the Molotov-von Ribbentrop
Pact of June, 1940. The Lithuanians had a traditional hatred of the
Russians dating back to Czarist oppression and the Bolsheviks' abortive
attempt to make Lithuania a Soviet state in 1918. (1c, p.273)
While the bulk of the Lithuanian populace was dismayed by the Red Army
invasion in 1940, the Jewish population welcomed them. For this, the Lithuanian
anti-Soviet underground movement (the Lithuanian Activist Front) saw the
Jews as traitors. (1d, p.211) In one of their political pamphlets (from
March 19, 1941), they made their anti-semitic position clear: "Lithuania
must be liberated not only from the Asiatic Bolshevik slavery but also
from the Jewish yoke of long standing . . . The old rights of sanctuary
granted to the Jews in Lithuania by Vytautas the Great are abolished forever.
. . " (1e, p.391) While it is true that many Jews embraced communism
(1a, p.350), for most the choice was simply between Soviet domination and
the obvious Nazi danger. Meanwhile, in the face of massive deportations
(30,000 - 45,000) of Lithuanian citizens (including 5,000 6,000 Jews)
to Siberia, many non-Jewish Lithuanians nourished the hope that Germany
would free them from the USSR. (1f, p.390; 5, p.11) So
it was that Jewish and non-Jewish Lithuanians found themselves adopting
diametrically opposed political positions. And just as the Jews had
greeted the Soviet invaders in 1940, the non-Jewish Lithuanian populace
took to the streets and greeted the Nazi invaders in 1941. I spoke
to one older Lithuanian woman, an American émigré of many
years, who was among those handing out roses to the Nazi soldiers as they
marched into Vilnius. She was just a young girl at the time, but
recalls the sheer joy of her friends and family that the Soviets were being
driven from the country. She confessed that she gave little thought
to the Jews; after all, the Soviets had treated Jews just as badly as they
had treated everyone else how could the Germans be any worse? For
her at least, and perhaps for some other Lithuanians who welcomed the Nazis
to their country, there was the bliss of ignorance. But if they were
blind to the Nazi's intentions toward the Jews, they could not remain so
for long. Meanwhile, some Jews left with the retreating Red Army.
(1a, p.351) Others joined the Sixteenth Lithuanian National Infantry Division,
part of the Red Army created by the Soviets to wage armed combat to regain
the Soviet Lithuanian Republic. (1c, p.273) Jews made up to one third
of the servicemen in the ranks of this division and formed the majority
among the regulars. (1g, p.323) Other Jews resisted the Nazis from within
the ghettos, such as the United Partisan Organization (FPO in the Yiddish
abbreviation) that helped Soviet POW's and carried out acts of sabotage
against the Germans. (1h, p.311). Despite these efforts, as has been
detailed above, within half a year of the beginning of the Nazi occupation,
most the Jewish inhabitants of Lithuania close to a
quarter of a million people - were annihilated. About 35,000
were kept alive a little longer in the ghettos of Vilnius, Kaunas and Siauliai
for slave labor. (4, p.13) In the blink of an eye, a centuries old
culture, a community, a people, had vanished. How this terrible deed
was accomplished is briefly described below.
The perpetrators.
Although historians debate the exact numbers of Lithuanians involved in
the killing of Jews, there is no doubt that the role of those who were
involved was considerable. As mentioned above, some sources estimate that
Lithuanian collaborators with the Nazis were responsible for at least half
of the deaths that occurred. In fact, in at least forty different
communities Jews were physically attacked even before the arrival of Nazi
troops. (1e, p.392) The brutality of some of these people has been documented.
They broke down walls and doors with axes and spades to find their victims.
(1d, p.213) In some cases they mocked, chased, and disrobed them before
killing them. Some eyewitnesses told of people clapping and singing
anthems at beatings and executions. (1, p.506-507) The Special Executionary
Squad (Sonderkommando) of 108 servicemen was predominantly formed by ethnic
Lithuanians. Its victims (including Jews and Communists) numbered
in the tens of thousands. By November 25, 1941, almost 19,000 Jews
were killed by the squad (and by members of the Nazi Einsatzkommando 9)
near
Paneriai, just outside of Vilnius. Here victims were marched
through the woods or brought by train, "registered," stripped naked, blindfolded,
and marched to the edge of large circular fuel storage pits where they
were shot at the rate of 100 per hour; efficiently falling into their own
mass graves. Later, to hide the evidence of their atrocities, Nazis
forced other Jews to exhume and burn the bodies in other large
pits. Those responsible for burning the bodies were kept in this
8-meter
deep pit to prevent their escape when they were not working.
Eventually, 70,000
Jews would be murdered and their bodies burned at Paneriai. (4, p.39-47)
Many Jews, especially
those in the ghettos, fell victim to organized
mass murders by units of police battalions. (1e, p.394) The Germans,
following the principle of "divide and rule," tended to send these battalions
to fight in other countries. So, for example, the Vilnius ghetto
was liquidated by Latvian and Estonian battalions. The Lithuanian
Auxiliary Police Battalions were formed of approximately 6,000 Lithuanian
soldiers who became part of the Soviet Army during the 1940 occupation
by the U.S.S.R. As war captives, the Nazis gave them two choices:
either join the police battalions or starve to death in the prisoner of
war camps. Most chose to join the police battalions, although about
3,500 of them eventually escaped their conscription. In addition,
there were about 2,500 volunteers. Of the 8,300 men who comprised
the Lithuanian police, 21 battalions were formed, of which 17 went to the
Eastern front and 4 were reserved for executions of Jews and Communists,
either in Lithuania, Poland, or Byelorussia. (1, p.510-511).
Notorious among
the Lithuanian killing fields is the 9th Fort of Kaunas (Kovno), a fortification
build by the Tsarist government in 1909, where Nazis murdered about 60,000
people, mostly Jews from the Kaunas ghetto and countries of Western Europe.
(1, p.451) An interesting report
from the SS leader concerning Nazi activities in Kaunas is quoted in
an exhibit in the Vilna Gaon Jewish State Museum and reproduced here.
It implicates the involvement of the partisan leader and Lithuanian journalist
Klimaitis in the Kovno pograms. It also suggests, with some twisted
logic, that this "inferior race" of Jews consisted, nonetheless, of "craftsmen
. . . indispensible at present for the repair of essential installations
. . . and for work of military importance." (The building
in Vilnius that housed the Jewish technicians needed to repair Nazi
motorcycles is still in use today. A plaque
memorializes
these victims, whose usefulness kept them alive longer than the others,
and a monument
erected after Lithuanian independence marks the place of their burial.)
Also notable in the Einsatzgruppe report quoted here is the suggestion,
at least from this Nazi commander's perspective, that Lithuanian cooperation
with the annihilation of the Jews was not always easy to achieve. (2) So
what do we know of the Lithuanians who witnessed, but were not involved
in, the murder of Jews?
The bystanders.
After visiting Lithuania several times, and spending the equivalent of
several months there, there is only one time I can recall seeing someone
become angry. One of my older students was telling a story of the
war, and she was still angry, almost six decades later at her mother!
It seems that the Nazis had roughed up their elderly Jewish housekeeper,
and her mother, having learned of this, marched down to the Nazi garrison
to complain. Luckily for her, her mother was sent away with a just
a warning if you interfere, you will share the Jews' fate and so will
all of your family members. "How could she have been so stupid as
to risk all of our lives like that?" my student fumed. The threat
given to her mother was not an idle one. We know of many Lithuanians
killed because they tried to help their Jewish neighbors. There
are probably many more of whom we will never know because they, their families,
and the Jews they tried to rescue - did not survive to tell their tale.
(1a, p.352; 5, p.15, 24)
Needless to say,
it is important to Lithuanians alive today, as well as to Jews everywhere,
to know that some people did care and did try, even at the risk of their
own and their family members' lives, to rescue Jews from the Holocaust.
Many cases have been documented, and some of these names are well-known
in Lithuania today Ona imaitè , Bronius Gotautas, Juozas Stakauskas,
Juozas Rutkauskas, Domas Jasaitis, and Sofija Jasaitienè, to name
a few. (5, p.15) Yad Vashem, the Holocaust Martyrs' and
Heroes' Remembrance Authority, was established by the Israeli Knesset in
1953 to, among other things, recognize those who tried to rescue Jews during
the war by conferring on them the title of Righteous Gentile. (5,
p.211) By the beginning of 2002, this title had been conferred upon 504
Lithuanians. (5, p.34) The Rescuers' Section at the Vilna Gaon Jewish
Museum has, during the ten years of its existence, documented a list of
the names of more than 3,000 people who rescued Jews in Lithuania, as well
as the names and numbers of Jews they rescued. (5, p.37) Still, one may
ask, why are these numbers not greater? Perhaps they were.
It already has been noted that not all altruists, or the people they attempted
to rescue, survived to become part of the historical record. Another
possibility is that the secrecy and censorship of the Soviet government,
which again took over Lithuania after the war, kept such information from
the historical record. Individuals would never be included in a list
of rescuers at that time if they did not hold communist views, or if they
had fled to the West, or if, because of their nationalistic stance, they
had been sent to Siberia, or if they were priests. At least 185 priests,
now confirmed as rescuers, were never listed as rescuers by the Soviets.
(5, p.25) Moreover, in this totalitarian state, all people - victims,
perpetrators, and bystanders - lost their national identity. Jews
murdered for being Jews became "Soviet citizens." (1e, p.396) Monuments
erected at mass graves indicated only that "Soviet people" or "citizens"
were buried there. (4, p.15) So, for example, the memorial
at Paneriai erected during the Soviet years has the inscription (in
Russian and Lithuanian): "Here in the Paneriai forest between July, 1941
and July, 1944, the Nazis shot over 100,000 Soviet people." Only
in 1990, with the beginning of the Lithuanian Revival Movement, was a new
text added in Lithuanian, Yiddish, Hebrew, and Russian. It reads:
"Among those to be ruthlessly murdered in the Paneriai forest were 70,000
Jewish men, women, and children." (4, p.41)
It is possible that
some rescuers are humble and do not desire recognition for their acts;
some, especially those living in foreign countries, may never have been
asked about their role during the Holocaust. (5, p.25) As time passes and
these rescuers pass on, the chances increase that their stories will be
lost forever. It is unfortunate then, that some historians indict
whole nations and their peoples because the ratio of Righteous Gentiles
to the general populace is so small. As a Jewish Lithuanian man in
Vilnius told me, one man with a machine gun could kill many hundreds or
even thousands of Jews, but it took the kindness and bravery of dozens,
maybe hundreds of people to save even one Jew.
So what is it that
we're counting, anyway? Is someone who beat a Jew while waiting for
the Nazi soldier to shoot him any less a murderer? (1, p.507) Is
someone who risked his life by giving bread to a Jew any less righteous
than someone who hid a Jew for years? And how do we count you if
you turn your back on your neighbor's child in order to save your own?
Lithuanians perhaps
can find some solace about this period of their history in the official
acts of their government before the war and since their independence from
Soviet rule in 1991. For example, it is estimated that during the
period of Lithuanian and Soviet rule in 1940 and 1941, the government issued
6,500 transit visas enabling Jews from Lithuania and nearby countries to
flee the area. We know that, in 1938, when Nazi Germany started openly
persecuting Jews, the Lithuanian government issued several formal protests.
(5, p.10) One of the first declarations issued by the Seimas (governing
body of Lithuania) on May 8, 1990, was a condemnation of "the annihilation
of the Jewish people during the years of the Nazi occupation in Lithuania."
(1e, p.397) Each of the known Jewish massacre/mass grave sites (about
200) has a memorial and a government promise that these places will be
preserved and tended. (4, p.15) Other towns have memorials
to their lost Jewish communities, such as this monument
in Druskininkai, whose population of 800 Jews were deported to the
Treblinka death camp in 1942. (6, p.335) The Jewish State Museum
soon will be moving to a new, larger building to accommodate their growing
files and exhibits. Of course, none of this can replace what had
been lost, but it can help us to remember.
Today there are
about 5,500 Jews and only a handful
of synagogues in Lithuania. No one can say what the future
will hold for these Litvaks.
Epilogue.
On my most recent visit to Lithuania, I was having dinner at the home of
two friends, a mother and daughter. I had the good fortune to meet
the (grand)mother of my friends and her sister, their (great)aunt.
After dinner, at my request, the grandmother, who was in her late 70's,
told us some stories of what it was like to grow up in Lithuania during
this terrible period of its history. She told us how her brother
had been shot in the back of his head by a Polish soldier during the occupation
of that army; how the Red Army would pass through the countryside, stopping
anywhere and taking anything they wanted; how another brother, just a little
boy, had almost been shot by a soldier who was vexed by the boy's interest
in his gun as he cleaned it; how a Russian soldier had been shot in their
yard by his superior officer because he stole the pancakes that the officer
had ordered her mother to make for him; and how, during the Nazi occupation,
her father and brother had been stunned while fishing on the river when
an escaping Jewish man popped his head up from the water and begged them
for their boat. They gave it to him, she said, but then worried for
the rest of the war that someone would find him, find their boat, ask about
their missing boat, turn them in, shoot them - all of them - for helping
the Jewish man to escape. Sitting there, listening to these childhood
tales told by this gentle and serene dear lady, I couldn't help but ask
her, "How is it, after witnessing all of this inhumanity, after growing
up with all this fear, you have become such a sweet and kindly person?"
She did not hesitate in her answer. "Others had it much worse than
me! I once worked with a man others told me about this, he never
did who, as a young Jewish boy, was forced by the Nazis to remove the
clothes from the bodies of children who had been shot. Yes, others
had it far worse then me." And of all the sad stories she told that
night, this one was the only one that brought tears to her eyes.
Sources
(1) Lithuanian State Jewish
Museum, (2001), Atminties Dienos The Days of Memory. International
Conference In Commemoration of the 50th Anniversary of the Liquidation
of the Vilnius Ghetto. October 11-16, 1993. Baltos Lankos,
Vilnius, Lithuania.
(a) Plasseraud, Yves. Jews
and Gentiles in Lithuanian History: An Outsider's View.
(b) Zingeris, Markas. Unlocking
the Gates of the Ghetto.
(c) Levin, Don. Some
Facts and Problems About the Fighting of Lithuanian Jews Against the Nazis
and Their Collaborators.
(d) Cohen, Nathan. The
Attitude of Lithuanians Towards Jews During the Holocaust as Reflected
in Diaries.
(e) Zuroff, E. The Memory
of Murder and the Murder of Memory.
(f) Jakubcionis, A. Lithuanian
Attitudes Towards Jews, the Vilnius Ghetto, Its Inmates, and Their Fate.
(g) Zizas, R. Armed Struggle
of the Vilnius Ghetto Jews Against the Nazis in 1941-1944.
(h) Margolis, R. The
Underground Antifacist Organization FPO in the Vilnius Ghetto.
(i) Faitelson, A. Place
of Murder 9th Fort.
(2) The Vilna Gaon Jewish
State Museum of Lithuania. Exhibit, August, 2002.
(3) Hilberg, Raul, (1992).
Perpetrators,
Victims, Bystanders: The Jewish Catastrophe, 1933-1945. Aaron
Asher books, New York, NY.
(4) Levinson, Yosif, (1997).
Skausmo
Knyga The Book of Sorrow. VAGA Publishers, Vilnius, Lithuania.
(5) Genocide and Resistance
Research Centre of Lithuania, (2002), Whoever Saves One Life . . .The
Efforts to Save Jews in Lithuania Between 1941 and 1944. Garnelis,
Vilnius, Lithuania.
(6) Spector, S. (Editor).
(2001).
The Encyclopedia of Jewish Life Before and During the Holocaust.
(Vol I. )
New York University Press, Washington Square, NY.
|